If you own a home in Miami, the choice between Citizens vs private home insurance in Florida is not entirely yours to make. Florida law lets you stay on Citizens only when a private offer comes in more than 20 percent above what Citizens charges for comparable coverage. At or under that line, you move.

Here is what the letter in your mailbox leaves out: how that test gets applied, when Citizens is still the better home, and which private carriers the state has cleared to take Citizens policies. (We write auto insurance in Miami too.)

Compare Citizens and Private Quotes

or call (786) 441-8985

What is Citizens Property Insurance?

Citizens is Florida’s state-backed insurer, created as the last resort for homeowners the private market would not take: older roofs, high-risk locations, past claims. Because the state stands behind it, it does not go out of business, which is why so many Florida policies piled up there after private carriers pulled out.

What changed by 2026?

The market moved, and Citizens shrank with it. By its own published count, Citizens held 1,407,805 policies in force on September 30, 2023 and 254,836 on September 30, 2026. Its 2026 rates came down too: an average 8.8 percent for homeowners multiperil policies and 5.5 percent for wind-only, set by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation and applied as policies renew. So Citizens is no longer the default, and no longer automatically the cheaper one.

Citizens vs private home insurance in Florida: the real differences

Coverage and price

Private policies are generally the more flexible of the two: higher liability limits, better contents protection, endorsements like water backup. Citizens is deliberately plainer. On price, neither side is reliably cheaper any more, which is exactly why the test below decides so much.

Can you stay on Citizens? The 20 percent test

Only if every private offer you get is expensive enough. Under Fla. Stat. 627.351(6)(c)5.a., a primary residence is not eligible for a Citizens policy unless the premium from an authorized private insurer is more than 20 percent greater than Citizens’ premium for comparable coverage. The test runs one direction only.

Put numbers on it. If your Citizens renewal is $4,000, a private offer of $4,800 or less makes you ineligible and you move. At $4,801 you may stay. A cheaper private offer does not protect your spot on Citizens, it ends it faster.

Two parts almost nobody mentions. The same 20 percent test applies to a brand new application, not just a renewal, so starting with Citizens does not get you around it. And if the home is not your primary residence, a second home or a rental, Fla. Stat. 627.351(6)(c)5.b. runs the same test and also counts take-out offers from an approved surplus lines insurer, on renewals from July 1, 2024.

The assessment risk, and why leaving does not erase it

If the Citizens account runs a projected deficit, Fla. Stat. 627.351(6)(b)3.a. lets its board charge every Citizens policyholder a surcharge of up to 15 percent of premium. When that is not enough, the next sub-subparagraph allows emergency assessments collected from policyholders of other insurers too, across most lines of business. A private policy cuts your exposure to a post-storm bill. It does not remove it.

When Citizens still makes sense

Citizens is the right answer for some homes, and we will tell you so. It fits when private carriers will not write your roof or price it absurdly, when several have already declined you, or when something about the house is simply hard to insure. That is the job it was built for.

One cost of staying: Citizens now requires flood coverage on most new and renewing personal residential policies that include wind, phased in by dwelling value and reaching every policy on January 1, 2027. Our Florida flood insurance guide covers what that means. For the home policy itself, see homeowners insurance in Miami.

When a private insurer is the better choice

For most Miami homeowners in 2026 the private market is worth a serious look if your roof is newer or you have a current wind mitigation inspection (shutters, straps, a hip roof), your claims history is clean, you want coverage you can actually customize, or you would rather cut your exposure to a post-storm surcharge than keep it.

See My Private Market Options

or call (786) 441-8985

Alternatives to Citizens insurance in Florida: what is actually out there

If you are hunting alternatives to Citizens insurance in Florida, you are probably holding a take-out notice or a renewal bill that finally made you go looking. The private market has real room for you now: Citizens’ own count fell from 1,407,805 policies to 254,836 in three years, and the state is deliberately moving policies back to private carriers.

Which companies are actually alternatives to Citizens?

The ones the state has cleared to take Citizens policies. Citizens publishes that list itself: insurers approved by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation to assume its policies through the depopulation program, each with a side-by-side comparison against the Citizens policy. It currently includes American Integrity, Florida Peninsula, Homeowners Choice, Manatee, Mangrove, Monarch, Security First, Slide, Southern Oak, Tailrow, Trident and TypTap, among others. Treat it as where to start, not a recommendation: which of them will write your roof, your zip code and your claims history is what a real quote settles.

What a take-out or depopulation letter means

Not that you are being dropped. An approved insurer wants to assume your policy, usually at a similar or better price. For take-out offers through depopulation, Fla. Stat. 627.351(6)(ii)3. says the risk leaves Citizens unless the private premium is more than 20 percent above the Citizens renewal premium, and that one applies only to a primary residence.

How to check an alternative before you switch

Do not just compare premiums. A cheaper policy that thins out replacement cost coverage, or comes from a shaky carrier, is not really an alternative. Check three things: the carrier’s Demotech or AM Best financial strength rating, whether it appears on Citizens’ list of approved take-out companies, and how its replacement cost and hurricane deductible compare with what you have now.

Quick answers

Do I have to leave Citizens if I get a take-out offer? You can stay only if the offer is more than 20 percent above your Citizens renewal premium. At or below that, you are not eligible.

Will a private carrier actually be cheaper? Sometimes, especially with a newer roof and a clean claims history. It depends on the property enough that the only honest answer is to get a real quote.

What if the carrier that takes my policy fails later? Florida’s guaranty fund (FIGA) pays covered claims when a licensed insurer becomes insolvent. Fla. Stat. 631.57(1)(a)2. caps each covered claim below $300,000, plus an additional $200,000 for the part of a homeowners claim relating to damage to the structure and contents.

How to know which one is right for you

Get both numbers in front of you. Ask for your Citizens renewal premium and a private quote on the same coverage, then see which side of the 20 percent line you land on. That one comparison settles it more often than any general advice about roofs and zip codes.

One thing worth noting: neither Citizens nor private home insurance covers flood damage. For that you’ll need a separate policy through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private flood insurer. This is especially important for Miami homeowners given Florida’s hurricane and storm surge risk.

That comparison is the work we do for Miami homeowners. IMAX Insurance Group has been an independent agency here since 2013, with offices on Bird Road and West Flagler Street, and we work in English and Spanish. Send us your Citizens declarations page and we will read it, line up private quotes beside it, and tell you plainly whether that 20 percent test already decides this for you. Call (786) 441-8985 or request a free quote.

Get My Free Home Quote

Published On: April 30th, 2026 / Categories: Home Insurance /